cat read flash error loader

cat s40 problem 1 is ok and another is dead
hi
i have cat s40 in fastboot mode not turn on fully
i have another s40 ok and working fine
i want to read in edl mode but cant-----error loader problem MSM 8909

W ID: 00000000E1009600 MSM8909
PK HASH: DF989E3C2BE41617A8FF5019AD996BF706BBD5D3EEE0DC4B9A 2F048F9224FA54
Checking database for suitable loader.....
Arhitecture:32 bits
Storage:EMMC
Sending loader, please wait..
Error untill sending loader!
Loader not accepted by phone.
Please select manually loader for this cpu.
Loader not accepted by phone.
i also selct manualy
pliz share ur info

now i want to read from working fone and write to another one how ?